York Pub Guide
   
THE PUBS - PUB CRAWLS - PUB GAMES - GUESTBOOK - EMAIL A PINT - LINKS HELP!CONTACT YPBLEGAL ISSUES
  PUB INFORMATION
  READ REVIEWS
  ADD REVIEW
  LINK TO THIS PUB
1328 page views
\n
Home > The Pubs > McMillans Cafe & Bar > Read All Reviews
McMillans Cafe & Bar
1 Rougier Street,
York.
YO1 1HZ
\n \n
\n
ADD REVIEW - READ ALL

could somebody please tell me where the regular sunday dj has gone?? mike brown? hasnt been there for 3 weeks running, he plays great music on a sunday.
 
Submitted by mr e on 13/03/2006 20:32:35

Nice to see TC back behind the dj stand last monday 27.2.06. At least u know how to play decent party choons that we all reconise, and humour the croud over the mic. well done. keep shanks behind the bar or tie him up in the cloakroom so we dont have to listen to his NO TALENT.
 
Submitted by dave east on 03/03/2006 10:00:09

nice tidy pub, decent friendly bar staff,dj mike brown getting better, plays great music on a sunday(funky house sessions). mondays have the worst dj on this planet(shanks)cant mix,no personality,boring to listen to,get TC back he's top bloke. saturdays play a decent selection of choons aswell. overall great pub apart from some clueless djs who should stick to flashing lights on and off cause thats all there any good at....
 
Submitted by york regular on 23/02/2006 10:21:19

Apparently we are not living 6000 years ago. Times have kinda moved on. Next it will be comments like.
"things were so much better during the plague"
Maccas is awesome. As is shown by the queues to get in every weekend.
 
Submitted by Beer on 18/02/2006 20:36:39

Whatever's wrong with discussing beer related topics?
Did you know, there's evidence of ale being brewed as early as 6000 years ago in the Tigris and Euphrates valleys of the middle east? (Thats about 3000 miles south east of Ibiza to you). And I bet even then, some establishments would charge over the odds for adulterated wares, and employ neolithic doormen still gathering their bearings from the ice age.
Some things never change.
Dominoes anyone?
 
Submitted by Steve the enchanter's apprentice and domino enthusiast on 17/02/2006 14:13:05

Tim & Steve must be related! It is only a guess mind you. They must like those dart/domino/sit in a corner and look at your beer pubs.
The where you go to talk about beer and beer related things. Awesome bar, simply the best in York. Music, staff and Decor. Nothing compares.
 
Submitted by AntiClogs on 13/02/2006 20:00:39

I whole heartily support Tim's pyromaniacal anti-twat ravings.

Amen, Tim
 
Submitted by Steve the enchanter's apprentice on 13/02/2006 16:08:48

Sounds like that twat/Tim is in denial!
 
Submitted by Freud Durst on 29/11/2005 16:54:02

why on earth would i want to go in there. i certainly wouldn't meet their requirements for entry - i.e. being a twat.
 
Submitted by tim the enchanter on 27/11/2005 15:21:13

re - Tim the Wuddeva.
You couldnt get in then?
 
Submitted by TimsHaemeroidPolip on 27/11/2005 04:33:47

one of the places in york which really should be burnt down. (preferably when it's full of its usual clientele on a saturday night)
 
Submitted by tim the enchanter on 26/11/2005 17:28:23

fao glenns posts in june. you are a mug and you got sacked for being unreliable and dipping your weeny in all the other staff there. i know cos i used to work there with you and like most others could not stand your miserable mug
 
Submitted by nexus staff on 23/11/2005 00:14:17

the punters must be there to provide the rest of us with some laughs- topman shirts, forty year old last chancersa and a supposed 'porn star' (bollocks) behind the bar! i'd rather eat my own hand than drink here.
 
Submitted by hand-eater on 04/07/2005 15:28:37

I believe TopMan have a very nice range of affordable "non crap" shirts with a few crap ones thrown in for good luck.
 
Submitted by Jacques on 30/06/2005 18:32:16

never been violent, never been bared. never been aloud in with a short sleave shirt. i must ware crap shirts. and you must work for them.
 
Submitted by drew on 25/06/2005 09:53:11

They obviously do'nt want your custom Drew. Have you tried Yates, I believe they have no such rules about tattoos. But there again, people have lost thier lives just trying to get in to Yates. I get in McMillans with tattoos and so (i think) does every other non violent human, with non offensive personal art that is reasonably sober when they get there. Maybe you are barred for some other reason?.
 
Submitted by Droo_py on 25/06/2005 04:14:55

a year on, and still cant get in this pub if you have tatoo's and are male. why? are the owners scared there flash cars and money will no longer work.
 
Submitted by drew on 25/06/2005 00:12:41

The owners of the venues are the same but they have separate management running them, shame one lot havent got half a clue between them tho
 
Submitted by Glenn on 11/06/2005 01:23:32

Glenn - To my knowledge the management of both those bars are the same people.
 
Submitted by Terry on 06/06/2005 21:43:00

A hell of a lot better than nexus!! the management have half a clue what theyre doing for a start!! if mcmillans swapped their management with nexus you would see a truly great bar in york (i should know as ive worked in nexus). The Dj mike brown is good, maybe talks too much but no ones perfect! get yourself here then off to gallery, its a cool chilled out, nice looking place to drink, unlike over the road!
 
Submitted by Glenn on 05/06/2005 03:38:36

OOOOhh. Can i where me Burbury baseball cap, tracky bottoms tucked into my white sports socks and Dunlop trianers in Toffs too?
 
Submitted by CHAVscum on 04/06/2005 04:08:47

Stuff Macs and Nexus, get yourselves to Toffs, its a great laugh, load smore chilled out and it doesnt matter if your fase doesnt fit or if you wear a bloody teeshirt or not!!!! Trust me.
 
Submitted by I understand on 31/05/2005 12:55:32

Tried to get in here last night. The doorman stopped me and my mate and asked us if we were from York. We told him we were from Acomb and he asked us to name some pubs to prove it. I told him pack of cards - the sun - acomb hotel and he still didn't believe me !! I then said Beagle and he infromed me that it has been closed down - which was funny cos I was in there on thursday??? What the hell is going on with these doorman ??
 
Submitted by Pissed Off on 29/05/2005 08:17:00

The last reviews are a little harsh!! The door staff are doing there job for everybodys safety! Get a life.
 
Submitted by jane on 30/03/2005 12:49:58

Mcmillans has changed loads, its much better now, get a mcmillans n nexus card, makes nights out in there cheaper xx
 
Submitted by Hayley on 23/03/2005 18:48:36


This place has always been wank and the last time i was in there the staff were grumpy (not to mention ugly) doormen were rude, drinks expensive and not to mention the 'stud' behind the bar who thinks he is all that when he is nothing of the sort!!! Overall, i wouldnt waste your time!
 
Submitted by Jen on 07/03/2005 12:22:06

and we know why you like it ey Ruth?!?!?!
 
Submitted by fi on 13/02/2005 14:34:10

plz all stop slaggin off Mcmillans, i think it is one of the top bars in York. i love it and suggest everyone visits here! go Mcmillans. many more drunk nites to come!
x
 
Submitted by Ruth on 05/02/2005 22:17:18

Shit.
If you want to pay ~£2.50 for a pint of watered-down, fizzy "John Smiths Extra Smooth", you've found your valhalla.
If you like Yates', you'll like this hole.
 
Submitted by Rich on 02/02/2005 15:53:50

since the refurb, its gradually going to its death. first they had food, which was shit, but in the last month or so the food improved vastly and was worth a visit during the day and chill out, then the food stopped and never returned. Been in on a fair few nights out my mates insist for the pretty blonde with big tats, but absolutely rammed, dj would never shut up, young plump lass that served me was miserable, the blonde was good though, blokes behind the bar too good looking make me feel ugly so went to flares and cheered myself up
 
Submitted by chickan man on 10/01/2005 17:38:52

Reading the bitchy animosity in the reviews below, I offer my own fearing a backlash that threatens to spill over like a watered down, over-priced pint.
Before the refurb, I thought this place was a sweaty dump. Since the refurb, I am astounded. The place has been transformed - into a sweaty dump with big screens and fancy lights.

Sorry McMillans lovers, dont think I'll ever have a good time in there.
 
Submitted by Steve The Tentative Reviewer on 07/01/2005 17:19:15

Last time I was in there it was called the Gob and Bucket. It was full of leather and denim, Silver Machine was played over and over again on the duke box. Must have changed a bit - reading the reviews below! Can't wait to check it out.
 
Submitted by John Jacoby on 02/11/2004 23:20:39

What's an A Level?
 
Submitted by lolagain on 01/06/2004 02:00:28

Did you do an A-level in punctuation?
 
Submitted by Rob on 31/05/2004 19:22:30

a, It Is'nt my pub.
b, It clearly states in my last post "most of the people in York are intelligent", meaning the majority of, or mainly, which also includes Chapelfields which i beieve is also a part of York.
c, The comments were squarely aimed at whoever Chapelfieldsuk is.
d, Obviously from his comments he is the type of person that scares bus's and taxi's from entering Chapelfields late at night.
e, Please keep going to Leeds.
 
Submitted by lolagain on 31/05/2004 05:02:09

"go after 7pm"
I do apologise!
 
Submitted by LaughsAtChapyidiot on 27/05/2004 04:20:22

For the same reason they let halfwit inbreds like the Chapelfields guy add reviews. I personally think most of the people in York are intelligent and well educated. Apart from that area where bus's and taxi's refuse to got after 7pm...remind me...oh thats it, Chapelfields. So if you don't like McMillans that's ok, its not aimed at you Mr Chapelfields.
 
Submitted by LaughsAtTheChapyidiot on 27/05/2004 04:17:57

The admin of this site are a waste of F**KING time. Why on earth are the promoters of McMillans and Nexus allowed on here to bump up the ratings of the poxy bars they promote.

Its simple. If you are a Yorkie with simple tastes, you go to Nexus or Mcmillians.

If you wanna try something with a little style and If you have the dosh go to Leeds
 
Submitted by CHAPELFIELDS.UK on 26/05/2004 20:53:07

Loved the atmosphere here when introduced to this place on Saturday for the first time. Nice friendly greeting by the door staff on arrival. Eat your heart out Grop & Ducket!!!
 
Submitted by Stephen Bellamy on 26/05/2004 00:01:18

Brillian Bar. Best in york since total refurb. Great service and value. Get there. Its The Bollocks
 
Submitted by Clicker Boy Ben on 24/05/2004 01:36:44

I was in here last night and the place was packed to a crazy degree. In terms of decor and style this is the best bar in York. The only thing that spoils it is the greedy management who insist on ramming the venue until the punters can hardly move.
 
Submitted by Baghead on 23/05/2004 15:22:41

Wouldnt let me in coz it woz full.
 
Submitted by Fungi on 16/05/2004 04:41:18

Bad Pub..had to queue. Doorstaff were rude. Drinks were overpriced...I don't recommend
 
Submitted by Ed on 13/05/2004 01:46:59

All those people make me laugh when they say its shit,everytime i go in its crap.....think about it...EVERYTIME i go in.why keep going in.One of those nobody goes there cos its too busy type comments.York is a tiny village but has some great bars.Nexus and McMIllans being the leading 2.
 
Submitted by bunch ofclueless dicks on 12/05/2004 22:21:28

Absolutely shite.Full of slappers and inbread monkeys.
 
Submitted by John on 12/05/2004 09:09:36

SHITHOLE !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Submitted by mcmillans is shit on 08/05/2004 20:43:40

Friday 8th may 2004. Toffs empty
Gallery empty. McMillans Ram Jam Squashy. Blah blah blah
 
Submitted by CrazyChic on 08/05/2004 03:52:09

blah blah blah. you should ban the promotioms guys from bumping up the ratings
 
Submitted by ettyave on 08/05/2004 01:27:26

Simply the epitomy of bar chic - and birthplace of the morris rave
 
Submitted by Elvis on 08/05/2004 00:45:58

Go to Leeds...don't bother with tese small time york wankers
 
Submitted by gashead on 07/05/2004 22:00:54

If that's what your into gashead, then i suggest Yates.
 
Submitted by NAKEDFLAME on 07/05/2004 14:09:51

Stereotype bullshit. You sleep shit and drink watered down piss. then you have a fight and a kebab
 
Submitted by gashead on 30/04/2004 22:42:16

Fantastic on a Friday and Saturday since its been re-done - cool big screens, dj's and good atmosphere. Way better than before
 
Submitted by Ellie on 29/04/2004 13:25:55

time to grow up not everyone with tatoos are going to fight. please give one good reason for the no tatoo rule.
 
Submitted by DREW on 24/04/2004 11:04:37

Independant (not owned by a brewery) does it again SIMPLY AWESOME...cleaning up time !!!!clueless chain bar/club managers come and learn....
 
Submitted by YorkBoy on 18/04/2004 04:36:13

Not for you common pissheads nemore since its bin dun out. No no, they now only let in the upper class tarts.
 
Submitted by Louise on 29/03/2004 19:10:55

How appropriate. An anagram of NapsterLives reflects his taste in pubs: "Tavern El Piss"
 
Submitted by AmusedAsAlways on 31/12/2003 06:53:23

Can only agree with Haggis. What about the 99% of the population that cannot stand "real ale" after all, the majority of real ales taste like mud or have been strained through my grandmas colostomy bag filter. Long live vodka...it gets u there faster and gives you the abillity not to bore your mates fqless, with meaningless verbal bollox " brewed in oak buckets, and tempered with barley moistenings"
 
Submitted by NapsterLives on 11/12/2003 03:08:30

Hey, as the best pubs in york only serve real ale and as all pubs on this site that have decent ratings serve real ale.....ALL BECOMES CLEAR.....reviews without valid email addys should be removed. Just like this one.
 
Submitted by haggis on 19/11/2003 04:56:04

ModerateMan: I think you missed out the words "IQ is" between "your" and "over" in the last sentence of your review.
 
Submitted by Tom Booze on 29/07/2003 09:39:31

Absolutely fantastic bar! one day all bars will be like this. Always busy, music, booze, girls, all a night out needs. If your over 40 this isnt going to be your scene.
 
Submitted by TheModeratemansDiscombobulator on 28/07/2003 06:11:46

Not so, Mr Moderate Man's Moderater.

A quick glance at reviews for the Hansom Cab (Martin) or Ye Olde Starre Inn (me) would show you otherwise. Maybe these two pubs would elicit the same bile and vitriol from you as McMillans does from us. And that's fine; everyone is entitled to an opinion. In fact, sixteen people have expressed their opinion on McMillans - resulting in an average rating of one. Make of that what you will.
 
Submitted by Tom Booze on 12/07/2003 13:09:14

Odd, isnt it? How Tom booze, Martin the thinking mans (wotevr). and a whole bunch of others that have posted opinions on bars in York have not mentioned the bars they like...mmmm
 
Submitted by The Moderate mans moderater on 28/06/2003 03:44:11

FULL OF BEAVER IVE BEEN GOIN FOR 10 YEARS.STILL GREAT.
 
Submitted by DIRTY DAZ on 14/06/2003 16:10:23

stinks of shit, nuff said
 
Submitted by dave on 09/06/2003 12:13:42

If Satan had asked his infernal minions to build him a pub, they would have chosen this place as a template. I try to give places the benefit of the doubt or look for some redeeming feature(s), but with this place I'm at a loss.

Absolutely vile. Don't go there.



 
Submitted by Tom Booze on 01/06/2003 12:55:00

Yes it is terrible!
But it fun to watch the desperadoes circle the young scantly clad girls!
 
Submitted by Don on 08/04/2003 16:45:22

Someone's given this a 10? Really? I'm sorry, I must be thinking of a different McMillan's. I've been in many times (I need new friends) and hated it every single time, whatever type of evening I've been having. Its full direness defies description, it's almost worth going in just to marvel at it. But not quite.
 
Submitted by Martin the Thinking Man's Drinking Man on 11/01/2003 03:34:43

A popular pre-clubbers bar though ultimately its just a shabby mess of green/orange neon lighting and dire music.
 
Submitted by Red T on 25/11/2002 16:08:58

i think its pretty cool u can go in get bottles for 88p, spend fuck all yet still get drunk and have a laugh and a dance in the process
 
Submitted by emma on 25/11/2002 12:26:50

A FANTASTIC PUB FOR A FRIDAY OR SATURDAY NIGHT BUT EXPENSIVE.
 
Submitted by DARREN CHARLTON on 21/11/2002 00:05:29

Good atmosphere, very friendly staff. people who slate this pub aught to stay at home with their coco and slippers
 
Submitted by Simon Holmes on 13/11/2002 13:34:03

I worked here. I know what I'm talking about.
 
Submitted by Andy on 13/09/2002 20:19:56

This pub is minted, you lot dont know what you are talking about - ugly loose women? thats the whole point of a night out you tits!
 
Submitted by Stephen on 11/09/2002 13:41:22

The only thing I can think of that's less fun than going to McMillans is going to Merlins. If it was a choice between that and having my head nailed to the floor, I'd be handing you the hammer already. Utterly dire.
 
Submitted by Louise on 25/07/2002 18:58:26

McMillan's? You're better off at McDonald's!
 
Submitted by Dave on 04/05/2002 17:48:24

Filth - ugly slappers - nobhead doorstaff - filth (see also Merlins)
 
Submitted by Marcus on 02/05/2002 00:58:23

I used to work here - it's shit. It apparently has a hip-hop night though.
 
Submitted by Andy on 14/04/2002 16:13:12


ADD REVIEW - READ ALL
 designed by Jonathan Irvine     HELP!CONTACT YPBLEGAL ISSUES